Does a disinherited child have a right to the compulsory share?
Table of Contents (5)
- When does a disinherited child lose his right to the reserved portion?
- What happens if the disinheritance is unjust?
- What steps should the disinherited son follow?
- Frequently asked questions for disinherited children
- Conclusion
When a parent disinherits a child in a will, the most frequent question is whether a disinherited child has a right to a reserved share.
The answer depends on several factors:
- whether the disinheritance is valid
- whether there is a legal cause
- whether the disinherited child decides to challenge it
In this article we explore this subject in depth as it relates to our notarial succession service.
When does a disinherited child lose his right to the reserved portion?
The short answer is that a disinherited child loses their right to the reserved portion (legítima) provided the disinheritance is properly justified in the will and there is a valid legal cause.
However, if the ground for disinheritance is not true or cannot be proven, the disinherited child can challenge the disinheritance and claim their share of the inheritance.
In Catalonia, the reserved portion (legítima) amounts to one quarter of the estate, which must be divided among all the deceased's children or descendants. Its regulation (which is set out in the Book IV of the Catalan Civil Code) and explanation can be found in depth in this article:
The testator may dispose of the remainder of the estate by making a notarial will, but cannot deprive his children of this part of the inheritance unless there is a legal ground for disinheritance.
We have already explained its causes in this other article:
If these grounds cannot be proven, the disinheritance could be declared invalid.
What happens if the disinheritance is unjust?
If the disinherited child considers that the cause is not true, they may go to the courts to challenge it. They must demonstrate that the reason given by the testator is not genuine or, failing that, that it does not meet the legal requirements.
If the judge declares that the causes are not justified, a disinherited child is entitled to a compulsory share and may claim it.
What steps should the disinherited son follow?
When a child has been disinherited, the usual procedure is as follows:
- Obtain a copy of the will.
- Check whether there is a cause for disinheritance.
- Analyse whether the cause is legal and can be proved.
- Initiate court proceedings if it is considered unjustified.
- With the judicial declaration, go to a notary's office for payment of the reserved portion and receive it from the heirs.
In many cases, before going to the courts it is possible to attempt a negotiated settlement among the heirs.
| Situation | Right to the reserved portion |
|---|---|
| Non-disinherited child | Is entitled |
| Disinherited child with a valid cause | Loses entitlement |
| Disinherited child without a legal cause | Can claim it |
| Disinheritance declared invalid by a judge | Regains entitlement |
Frequently asked questions for disinherited children
Disinheritance is only valid if it is based on a legal cause provided for by law and if that cause is expressly stated in the will.
Among the most common causes are serious mistreatment of the parent, refusing to provide maintenance, or having committed certain offences against the testator or their family.
No. For the disinheritance to be valid, the will must expressly state the legal grounds for disinheritance.
If the disinherited child contests the disinheritance, the heirs who benefit from it must prove that the cause indicated in the will is true. This is laid down in article 451.20 of Book IV of the Civil Code of Catalonia and in article 850 of the Civil Code of common law.
Conclusion
The answer to the question "Does a disinherited child have a right to a legitimate portion?" depends on whether the disinheritance is valid or not.
If there is a legal cause and it can be proven, the disinherited child will lose their right. However, if the cause is not true or cannot be proven, the child can challenge the disinheritance and claim their share of the inheritance.
In matters of succession, the legitimate portion is a right protected by law and its loss can only occur in very specific circumstances.
If you need advice on succession, at our notary in Barcelona we can advise you on the legal options and the steps to take. You can find us on Avenida Diagonal, between Francesc Macià and Passeig de Gràcia.